THE HERE AND NOW IN CANADIAN BOXING
By Brian Zelley
*Trying to select the top ten
active Canadian professional boxers
is not an easy task as it requires some
effective and readily available
yardsticks.
The big issue is do we base it on their overall
record or their most recent performanc.
If we were trying to pick the best
Canadian boxers of all times with
names like Jimmy MCLarnin,
Art Hafey, George Chuvalo and
many others then the complete
record broken down into early
years before any world title
fights, the championship years
for National and/or world titles,
and then the post championship
years.
The Current active fighters do not have
a complete record to be able to put them
in any All Time Top Canadian Boxers list, as what happens in the
future bouts will have signigicant relevance as to their final
standing until they are edged out by some new list to the top
fighters of Canada.
So in judging them today, then their position on the list of the
Top Ten Active Canadian boxers should be based on their most recent
bout. And, how we analyze that bout is not only decided by the result
but the quality of the opponent in that fight. If the potentiak rio rwb
candidate was facing an ordinary fighter with a so-so record that
would not likely be that significant in the rankings, but a recent victory
over a top ranked boxer at the top of his game would likely be very
important in the selection for a moment in time. Then after each fight
by any active boxer, the selection committee or even an individual
would have to rethink the standings for another moment in time.
Recent Listings
*A recent listing based on BoxRec data and reported by
Canadian site: Boxing Canadiana has listed the
following male boxers from one to ten:
Now this list includes the ring
records of the boxers and 3 have
complete victories but it does not
show the quality of the opponents.
And that important consideration
is one is only good as their last
bout, but still quality of the
opponent should be taken into
considertion.
The other factor is which active Canadian professional boxers
that have won their previous bout against a top quality boxer
or even done well in a world title fight has been left off of the
special list of the TOP BOXERS OF CANADA in 2012?
Pitfalls In Any Selection:
When it comes to picking the top ten boxers of all time
five of the ones that will appear in my list would
include:
SUGAR RAY ROBINSON - HENRY ARMSTRONG
WILLIE PEP - ROBERTO DURAN - EDER JOFRE
But, then it gets tricky with so many greats and legends
to sort out such as Barney Ross, Tony Canzoneri, Jimmy
Wilde, Joe Louis, Archie Moore and countless others
from heavyweight such as Muhammad Ali and Rocky Marciano
to the lighter fighters such as Carlos Ortiz, Emile Griffith,
Flash Elorde, Billy Conn, Marcel Cerdan, Mickey Walker,
Harry Greb and George Dixon, and many more.